Home > Legal articles > UsedSoft v Oracle opens up market for second-hand software licences
The Court of Justice of the European Union (the “CJ”) handed down a landmark decision on 3 July 2012 in the case of software licence reseller UsedSoft v Oracle that opens up the market for second-hand software licences.
The Court of Justice of the European Union (the “CJ“) handed down a landmark decision on 3 July 2012 in the case of software licence reseller UsedSoft v Oracle that opens up the market for second-hand software licences.
Oracle’s business model is not to “sell” software but to provide an intangible copy of its software, which can be downloaded from its website, and to grant a perpetual licence for this intangible copy. The licence terms prohibit the customer from transferring the licence to third parties. This system prevents a market for second-hand software licences. Based on this licensing model, Oracle opposed the resale of “used” Oracle licences by UsedSoft, a reseller of second-hand software. UsedSoft argued that under EU copyright law a software supplier who sells a copy of a software program cannot oppose the further sale of such copy based on his copyright (the “exhaustion doctrine”). Oracle argued that the exhaustion doctrine does not apply to intangible copies which are licensed rather than sold. The CJ now concluded that when a copyright holder makes available to his customer a copy – tangible or intangible – and at the same time concludes a perpetual licence agreement in lieu of payment of a fee this equals a “sale” of the software and the copyright holder exhausts its exclusive distribution rights.
Download
Please download the legal alert here in English.
15 July 2020
17 December 2019
16 December 2019
ECJ provides more options for forum shopping in connection with Community designs
15 October 2019
The General Court’s Starbucks and FIAT rulings: what’s new and what’s not
17 July 2019
Trend: parallel trade and geo-blocking in the distribution chain scrutinised
17 July 2019
The Hague Court of Appeal gives guidance on standard essential patent licensing and FRAND
16 July 2019
Commission’s decision to investigate Nike tax rulings explained
17 April 2019
ECJ’s landmark ruling on “skinny labeling” impacts practice for generic medicinal products
17 April 2019
Copyright holders one step closer to better protection in digital market
14 March 2019
Plant-related patent uncertainty as European Patent Office changes view again
De Brauw Blackstone Westbroek
Claude Debussylaan 80
1082 MD Amsterdam
The Netherlands
P.O. Box 75084
1070 AB Amsterdam
The Netherlands