In May 2018, the US stepped out of the JCPOA and subsequently reimposed its secondary sanctions against Iran, threatening non-US companies that continued trading with Iran with a range of penalties. Trade between Iran and the EU significantly declined as a result, seriously limiting the benefits of the deal for Iran. The US also imposed additional sanctions against Iran, most recently against its construction, mining, manufacturing and textiles industry.
Since the reimposition of US secondary sanctions, Iran has gradually reduced its compliance with its commitments under the JCPOA. On 5 January 2020, Iran announced that it would no longer comply with the last operational restriction on its nuclear program, relating to the number of its uranium enrichment centrifuges. Without formally withdrawing from the agreement, Iran announced that, in essence, it would no longer abide by the JCPOA – unless the US sanctions were lifted.
In response, the E3 have now triggered the dispute resolution mechanism, as provided in the JCPOA. The E3 have also expressed their intention to resolve the impasse through constructive diplomatic dialogue and to preserve the agreement.
Dispute resolution procedure
The steps in the JCPOA dispute resolution mechanism are as follows.
The UN Security Council includes five permanent members – China, France, Russia, the UK and the US. Each permanent member has a veto right in terms of making substantive resolutions. Given its constitution, it would seem unlikely for the UN Security Council to continue the lifting of sanctions or modify the reimposition of UN sanctions, should the E3 choose to give notification of significant non-performance.
Recommendation to the EU Council
If the E3 deem the issue a significant non-performance of Iran’s obligations under the JCPOA, they may withdraw their commitments under the framework. In addition to notifying the UN Security Council of significant non-performance, they may then also opt, together with the EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, to recommend that the EU Council reintroduce EU sanctions against Iran. Pursuant to EU Council Declaration (2015/C 345/01), the EU Council is committed to reintroducing without delay all EU nuclear-related sanctions that have been suspended and/or terminated on the basis of the joint recommendation. Alternatively, it would seem possible that the E3 and the High Commissioner will not make such a recommendation, but that they will suggest to the EU Council to reintroduce the EU nuclear-related sanctions against Iran not all at once, but only in part or step by step.
Implications for EU companies
It is clear that different scenarios are possible. However, the risk that the UN and/or EU sanctions against Iran will be reimposed has significantly increased.
A reimposition of sanctions may include:
Any such reimposed sanctions will prohibit companies to enter into new contracts for activities or with parties targeted by those sanctions.
As to already existing contracts, the JCPOA provides that any reimposed UN sanctions will not have retroactive effect on contracts concluded before the reimposition, “provided that the activities contemplated under and execution of such contracts are consistent with this JCPOA and the previous and current UN Security Council resolutions”. This proviso seems to leave some room for interpretation. As a result, it remains to be seen how this would work out in practice. In any case, it seems likely that any reimposed sanctions may restrict companies in the execution of the contracts concerned. For example, reimposed product-related restrictions may limit companies in the procurement of certain supplies or services that they need to fulfil their contractual obligations.
For these reasons, companies conducting business in Iran would be well advised to closely follow these developments. They should also assess, ahead of time, whether any of their activities are covered by any of the UN or EU sanctions against Iran that might be reimposed.
Naturally, we will keep on monitoring the situation and update you on important further developments when they transpire. Also, please feel free to contact us, should you want to discuss the potential implications for your company’s activities.
De Brauw Blackstone Westbroek
Claude Debussylaan 80
1082 MD Amsterdam
P.O. Box 75084
1070 AB Amsterdam